Matthew Schaefer scores hat trick in Islanders' 5-1 win over Columbus
Fantasy hockey: The defenseman posted three goals and nine shots in 23:23 against the Blue Jackets, well above his recent averages. Fantasy impact.
By Fantasy Roundup Staff · November 18, 2026 · Updated November 18, 2026
Matthew Schaefer scored three goals on nine shots in 23:23 of ice time as the Islanders defeated the Blue Jackets 5-1 on Tuesday, November 17. The defenseman added a block and finished plus-2 in the win.
The hat trick pushes Schaefer well above his recent averages of 0.70 points and 2.6 shots per game. His underlying play grades 93 out of 100 among defensemen (shots, scoring chances and ice time), a read on how sustainable his scoring is.
Fantasy impact
Player by player
Matthew Schaefer
Schaefer's three-goal performance came in 23:23 of ice time, just under his 24:37 average. The nine shots represent more than three times his usual 2.6 per game, while the three points are more than four times his 0.70 average. He logs 2:58 on the first power-play unit, fourth among all Islanders skaters.
The underlying numbers support treating Schaefer as a legitimate fantasy asset. His 93 process grade ranks among the best at the position, measuring his shot volume, scoring chances and ice time. With four games remaining this week (Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday, Monday), Schaefer offers streaming value in formats where defensemen are scarce.
What to do
• Stream Schaefer for his four games this week if you need defenseman production.
• Consider Schaefer a reliable source of shots and ice time given his 93 process grade.
• Expect Schaefer's scoring to settle closer to his 0.70 points per game, though his elite underlying play supports rostering him.
Schedule this week
Quick answers
What does this mean for Matthew Schaefer in fantasy hockey?
It helps his fantasy value. Breakout line: 3 goals, 9 shots in 23:23. 3 points, 9 shots against recent averages of 0.70 points, 2.6 shots and 24:37 a night.
Should I start Matthew Schaefer this week?
Yes. the Islanders plays 4 games this week, and he has averaged 0.70 points per game.
Players in this story
- Matthew Schaefer (D, NYI) · fantasy outlook: value up
Lineups for the teams in this story
- Islanders lineup and lines tonight (New York Islanders)
- Blue Jackets lineup and lines tonight (Columbus Blue Jackets)
- NHL starting goalies tonight
More fantasy hockey news
- Week 8 fantasy hockey waiver wire pickups, updated for the rest of the week: Snuggerud, DeBrusk and Nazar
- Trevor Connelly records two assists in Golden Knights overtime loss
- Mikko Rantanen posts four points in Stars overtime win
- Connor Bedard exits with shoulder injury, four-game week in jeopardy
- Cutter Gauthier hat trick lights up Ducks loss to Blues
- Joel Eriksson Ek posts four points in Wild's 7-3 win over Predators
- Matt Boldy posts three-point night in Wild's 7-3 rout of Predators
- Logan Mailloux posts three-point night in Blues' win over Ducks